Tag: Ninth Circuit
Copyright Law Blocks Student-Athlete Suit over Sale of Game Photos
Today, the Ninth Circuit held in Maloney v. T3 Media that former collegiate athletes’ right of publicity claims arising out of the licensing of their photos by T3 Media were barred by copyright law. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court opinion in the case. Unfortunately, rather than clarifying the district court’s muddled analysis, it...
Supreme Court Punts on O’Bannon v. NCAA
On Monday, the Supreme Court denied the petition for certiorari in O'Bannon v. NCAA, a Ninth Circuit decision from September 2015. The decision upheld the application of antitrust laws to the NCAA. The decision in O'Bannon rested in part on the conclusion that the use of the players' names and likenesses in videogames required licensing....
Professors File Brief Supporting Review of O’Bannon and Fixing Right of Publicity Mess
Last week I filed an amicus brief co-authored by Eugene Volokh and signed on to by 28 Constitutional Law and Intellectual Property Law professors supporting the petition for certiorari in O'Bannon, and in particular calling for guidance on the conflict between the First Amendment and the right of publicity. As I have written, O'Bannon v....
NCAA Petitions Supreme Court to Protect Uses of Athletes’ Names & Likenesses
Last week, the NCAA filed a petition for certiorari with the Supreme Court in O'Bannon v. NCAA. The bulk of the petition seeks to overrule the Ninth Circuit's decision that the NCAA rules requiring amateurism violate the Sherman Act and antitrust law. Part of the petition also challenges the Ninth Circuit's "flawed intepretation of the...
The Ninth Circuit Resurrects Sarver
On Christmas Eve, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals resubmitted Sarver v. Chartier for consideration. I posted earlier about this long-lingering right of publicity lawsuit arising out of the Academy-Award winning film The Hurt Locker. If the Supreme Court grants certiorari in Davis v. Electronic Arts—a case being discussed in conference later this week—look for...
Players Associations File Brief Supporting Reversal in Maloney
Earlier this week the NFL, MLB, NHL and MLS players associations filed an amicus brief supporting the NCAA student-athletes' appeal from a decision that held that their right of publicity claims were preempted by copyright law. The student-athletes objected to the sale of photographs that were licensed by the NCAA and that included images of...
Sarver Tells Ninth Circuit – Hey, Don’t Forget About Me!
In a letter filed this week in the Ninth Circuit, Sarver’s attorney reminds the Ninth Circuit that this case, which was argued on May 9, 2013, still has not been decided by the Court of Appeals. Sarver v. The Hurt Locker, LLC, involves a right of publicity claim (among other claims) for the alleged use...
Constitutional Law and Intellectual Property Law Professors Call on Supreme Court to Review Davis
Professor Eugene Volokh (UCLA) and I filed a brief today in support of granting certiorari in Davis v. Electronic Arts. The brief was signed on to by many leading constitutional law and IP law scholars. We call on the Supreme Court to address the disarray among lower courts about how to analyze the First Amendment...
Decision in O’Bannon v. NCAA Provides Right of Publicity Edge to the NCAA
The Ninth Circuit’s decision last week upholding the application of antitrust laws to the NCAA, has several implications for student-athletes and their rights of publicity. The appellate court’s holding that the NCAA could retain its rules requiring students to remain amateur means that student-athletes cannot receive compensation for uses of their names or likenesses, or...
Ninth Circuit Denies Rehearing in Davis v. Electronic Arts
The Ninth Circuit denied rehearing in its controversial decision in Davis v. Electronic Arts that the use of real professional athletes identities in a video game was not protected by the First Amendment. This decision leaves at risk numerous expressive and nonfiction works that include portrayals of historical fiction. For a detailed analysis of why...